Buffalo Creek
By Jessica Carcoana · Updated September 2026
Wellington's largest established subdivision at 434 homes in the northern part of town, a mix of ranch, two-story, four-level, and tri-level plans averaging 1,500–2,800 finished square feet with 2–3 car garages on well-maintained lots. A solid mid-range residential neighborhood with pool access and easy I-25 proximity.
At a glance
Community Anchors
- Wellington Community Park (30 acres, softball fields, batting cages, tennis courts, dog park, splash pad, walking trails, picnic areas)
- Downtown Cleveland Avenue (local shops, restaurants, Sparge Brewing, Wellington Farmers' Market)
- Ridley's Family Market (primary grocery)
- Wellington Middle-High School (new facility opened 2022, grades 6–12, 1,500-student capacity)
- Eyestone Elementary School (PK–5, Poudre School District)
- Fort Collins Country Club (short drive south)
- Wellington State Wildlife Area (nearby hunting and birding)
- Poudre Trail and Northern Colorado trail network (accessible via Fort Collins)
Schedule a call with Jessica to discuss the Wellington market and homes in Buffalo Creek.
Book a Meeting
Where it sits
Inside Wellington. Platted boundary.
Quick answersQuestions about Buffalo Creek
Where is Buffalo Creek?
Buffalo Creek is in Wellington, about 0.8 miles north of the Wellington center. The map on this page shows its platted boundary from county records.
When was Buffalo Creek built?
Homes in Buffalo Creek were built between 2003 and 2008 (early 21st century).
Is there an HOA in Buffalo Creek, and what does it cost?
Buffalo Creek has a homeowners association. Dues run about $30–$50/mo; confirm the current figure with the association before you buy.
What amenities does Buffalo Creek have?
Buffalo Creek amenities include neighborhood park, community pool, HOA-managed common areas, and trash removal included.
How big are the lots in Buffalo Creek?
Typical lots in Buffalo Creek run 6,500–8,000 sqft.
Which schools are near Buffalo Creek?
Schools near Buffalo Creek include Eyestone Elementary and Wellington Middle-High School. Verify enrollment eligibility by address.
About how many homes are in Buffalo Creek?
County parcel records show about 450 parcels in Buffalo Creek.
How high is Buffalo Creek?
Buffalo Creek sits at about 5,230 feet above sea level.
Parks and Schools
- Buffalo Creek Park
- Wellington Community Park
- Eyestone Elementary
- Wellington Middle-High School
Verify school assignment by address with the district. Attendance boundaries do not follow neighborhood lines.
Commute and Access
- 2 minI-25
- 5 minCO-1 / Cleveland Ave
- Washington Ave
Transit in Wellington: No local bus service within Wellington · FLEX regional bus route (Fort Collins to Cheyenne, WY, limited stops) · I-25 provides 10-minute drive to Fort Collins, 45-minute drive to Cheyenne
Other Neighborhoods in Wellington
- The Knolls at Wellington South$430K–$540K (estimated)
- Park Meadows$440K–$560K (estimated)
- The Meadows$400K–$525K (estimated)
- Harvest Village$350K–$575K
- Sage Meadows$390K–$540K
- Mountain View Ranch$470K–$505K
- Old Town Wellington$350K–$500K (estimated)
- Wellington Village Condos$280K–$340K (estimated)
- Indian Creek Meadows$900K–$1.4M (estimated)
- Sage Farms$425K–$600K (anticipated, estimated)
About This Profile
This profile of Buffalo Creek was researched in April 2026. It was last reviewed in September 2026. The price range is an estimate built from comparable nearby neighborhoods rather than from direct listings. Amenity coverage is moderate, and some features rest on a single source. 434 homes; price estimated from Wellington median and comparable subdivision comps.
Data sourced from direct and indirect online resources. Details are subject to change over time as we continue to research this area.