Sheely Addition

By Jessica Carcoana · Updated September 2026

Sheely Addition began as 40 acres of the Birky farm that Arthur Sheely bought in 1951 and sold two years later to developers Ben Olds and Bert Redd, who laid out curving streets without curbs or sidewalks south of the CSU campus off West Prospect Road. Its core, the 1600 and 1700 blocks of Sheely Drive, holds 11 mid-century Modern houses of 2,000 to 3,000 square feet with floor-to-ceiling glass and wood and stone finishes, designated a Fort Collins landmark district in 2000 when the oldest dated to 1953, while the surrounding blocks filled in through 1968 with ranch and Colonial Revival homes on 0.15 to 0.30 acre lots. The Gardens on Spring Creek at 2145 Centre Avenue and the Spring Creek Trail are about half a mile southeast. Centre Avenue and Shields Street bound the neighborhood, Prospect Road leads to campus in minutes, and the MAX line on Mason Street runs about half a mile east.

At a glance

Price Range
$350K$1.1M
$500K–$800K
Mid-tier of Fort Collins
Era Built
1950–1968
19002026
Mid-Century
various builders
Community Anchors
  • Old Town Fort Collins (100+ restaurants, shops, breweries, events)
  • Colorado State University campus and events
  • New Belgium Brewing, Odell Brewing, 20+ craft breweries
  • Horsetooth Reservoir (boating, swimming, fishing, rock climbing)
  • Horsetooth Mountain Open Space (29 miles of trails)
  • Cathy Fromme Prairie Natural Area (trails and wildlife)
  • Fossil Creek Reservoir Natural Area (1,400 acres, 180+ bird species)
  • Spring Creek Trail (7-mile paved urban trail)
  • Poudre River Trail
  • Power Trail (north-south bike corridor)
  • Gardens on Spring Creek (community botanic garden)
  • Fort Collins Museum of Discovery
  • Lincoln Center (performing arts)
  • Edora Park and Rolland Moore Park (major rec centers)
  • Collindale Golf Course and Southridge Golf Course
  • City Park (pool, playgrounds, tennis)
  • 960+ acres of developed parks, 45+ miles of paved trails
Considering Sheely Addition?

Schedule a call with Jessica to discuss the Fort Collins market and homes in Sheely Addition.

Book a Meeting
Jessica Carcoana, Licensed Realtor and Mortgage Loan Advisor

Where it sits

Inside Fort Collins. Platted boundary.

Typical Lot0.15–0.30 acres
Home TypesSingle-family
AmenitiesSpacious ranch-style and Colonial Revival homes, Proximity to Gardens on Spring Creek, Access to CSU campus events, Larger-than-average lots for the area
Quick answers

Questions about Sheely Addition

Where is Sheely Addition?

Sheely Addition is in Fort Collins, about 1.3 miles south of the Fort Collins center. The map on this page shows its platted boundary from county records.

When was Sheely Addition built?

Homes in Sheely Addition were built between 1950 and 1968 (mid-century). Builders on record include various builders.

What amenities does Sheely Addition have?

Sheely Addition amenities include spacious ranch-style and Colonial Revival homes, proximity to Gardens on Spring Creek, access to CSU campus events, and larger-than-average lots for the area.

How big are the lots in Sheely Addition?

Typical lots in Sheely Addition run 0.15–0.30 acres.

Which schools are near Sheely Addition?

Schools near Sheely Addition include Moore Elementary, Blevins Middle School, and Rocky Mountain High School. Verify enrollment eligibility by address.

About how many homes are in Sheely Addition?

County parcel records show about 92 parcels in Sheely Addition.

How high is Sheely Addition?

Sheely Addition sits at about 5,030 feet above sea level.

Nearby

Parks and Schools

Nearby Parks
  • Gardens on Spring Creek
  • Spring Creek Trail
  • Edora Park
Nearby Schools
  • Moore Elementary
  • Blevins Middle School
  • Rocky Mountain High School

Verify school assignment by address with the district. Attendance boundaries do not follow neighborhood lines.

Getting Around

Commute and Access

  • 1 min
    Centre Ave
  • 2 min
    Shields St
  • 3 min
    Drake Rd

Transit in Fort Collins: Transfort MAX bus rapid transit (Mason Corridor, Downtown to South Transfer Center) · Transfort local bus routes throughout city · Bustang regional service to Denver (2+ hours) · Fort Collins bike share (FC Bikes) · 280+ miles of bike lanes and trails (Platinum-level Bicycle Friendly Community)

Explore

Other Neighborhoods in Fort Collins

See all 45 Fort Collins Neighborhoods →

About This Profile

This profile of Sheely Addition was researched in April 2026. It was last reviewed in September 2026. The price range is an estimate built from comparable nearby neighborhoods rather than from direct listings. Amenity coverage is moderate, and some features rest on a single source.

Data sourced from direct and indirect online resources. Details are subject to change over time as we continue to research this area.